Mystery Scene Magazine

Daily Miscellany

"One nude woman is beautiful but a nudist colony is only silly."

—Fred Fitch, God Save the Mark, 1967, by Donald Westlake


Search Book Review Database

Search by Book Title or Author Last Name:


Mysteries about war

Saturday, 21 August 2010 20:54
The recent blog about authors going on the USO tour in Iraq to visit the troops made me think about how the mystery genre has handled war and its aftermath.

And I think that the mystery genre has done the best at depicting war, its affect on soldiers and civilians and on countries. I don't think mainstream fiction has done as good a job or as an intensive job as have mystery writers.

It can be from a mention of a character's background -- as Michael Connelly does with Harry Bosch, a Vietnam War veteran, or the creation of an iconic character as David Morrell did with First Blood, which introduced Rambo.
alt
It doesn't matter which war, either, because the issues are the same, no matter the era. Our complicated feelings about war don't really change through the years; soliders during and after World War II dealt with the same issues that affect our men and women who have fought and are fighting in the Persian Gulf.
 
Here are just a few authors who have used war as a background to intriguing mysteries. The trick that each of these authors has mastered is making the reader care about an individual killing amid so much death. So the theme that emerges in each of these mysteries is that every death matters.

In no particular order:
alt
John Connolly: The Whisperers -- Connolly uses his series about the volatile private detective Charlie Parker to show a different side of the stress and fears that soldiers cope with returning from Iraq.

Charles Todd: The Red Door -- Todd again shows that this series about Ian Rutledge, a battle-fatigued World War I veteran and Scotland Yard detective, is as fresh and original as when the shell-shocked detective debuted 12 novels ago.

Charles Todd: An Impartial Death -- While Todd's series about Ian Rutledge looks at post-WWI, this new series about British army nurse Bess Crawford is set two years into the Great War when an end, let alone a victory, seemed impossible.

Kelli Stanley: City of Dragons --  Stanley never misses a beat as she also shows San Francisco’s hidden corners, seething emotions in the days before WWII. Stanley expertly depicts an America that will be pulled into a world war within a year and city fractured by racial prejudice against the Japanese.

James R. Benn: Rag and Bone -- Benn's fifth WWII novel featuring Lt. Billy Boyle is wrapped around politics and war secrets as the story involves a look at the execution of thousands of Polish officers in the Katyn Forest.

Sara Paretsky: Body Work -- The Chicago author looks at post-war stress of young veterans of the Iraqi war in her 14th novel featuring tough private detective V.I. Warshawski. 

altJacqueline Winspear: The Marriage of Love and Death -- The aftermath of WWI and how it changed British society are realized through the plucky heroine Maisie Dobbs.

Rennie Airth: The Dead of Winter -- Airth’s third police procedural delivers an astute view of London and rural England during the waning days of World War II.

Christopher Rice: Blind Fall -- Rice looks at gay soldiers as a Marine teams up with the lover of his murdered captain to avenge the death of the man he trusted most.

Yes, this is just a smattering of the many authors who use war in their mysteries. Tell us who are your favorites. 
 

Comments  

 
0 #3 Sharon Wildwind 2010-08-24 09:50
I agree completely that mysteries do a good job with war and veterans. One of my favorite stories is about Ed McBain. In his 87th precinct series, the wars that the detectives had served in kept changing. First it was World War II, then Korea, then Viet Nam, and possibly even into Iraq.
Quote
 
 
0 #2 Fran 2010-08-23 11:32
Michael Gruber's "The Good Son" looks at the war in Pakistan, and Robert Dugoni's "Wrongful Death" examines the complexities of the war in Iraq. Both are well written, and readers learn about both cultures while on serious roller-coaster rides.
Quote
 
 
0 #1 Dan Gordon 2010-08-22 14:17
Oline: Especially enjoyed this piece about mysteries and war. Will be looking for them when I get my new Kindle, any day now. I've always been a big fan of Alan Furst (am I the only one who thinks his voice sounds a lot like former Sun-Sentinel travel editor Thomas Swick?)and Philip Kerr's hardboiled series on German detective Bernie Gunther, which stretches from Weimar times to postwar Germany, Peronist Argentina and Mafia-ridden Havana. So far. Just beginning work on a novel. Last one stunk. As a copy editor, I should know. Hope to make it to next year's Florida mystery convention. Dan
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh